Greed or Ignorance – Which Costs More?
by Larry Goldsmith, C.P.A., J.D., C.F.F.A. Was it legal greed or ignorance that deprived a divorcing wife her reasonable financial settlement and left her destitute after a 30 year marriage? Recently a woman in distress called me to perform forensic accounting to ascertain and document the amount of income her husband truly received from a cash business. The attorneys charged hundreds of thousands of dollars in fee, collected dozens of boxes of financial documents and did nothing to prove the husbands actual cash earnings. Her quivering voice explained that the family business generated cash that was not reported for tax purposes and was never deposited into bank accounts. She believes the cash is now stashed with his relatives. In a divorce, it is common for parties to believe that their spouse has been hiding cash or hiding income. In most situations the beliefs are unfounded. The best service that a forensic accountant can perform in these situations is to be honest and ease the party’s fears. In other cases, as in the aforementioned case, the discovery period had terminated. Discovery is the time period where the court permits parties in a law suit to gather information, documents, and engage in depositions from the other party. The attorney never told them that an independent forensic account was needed. Many lawyers believe that their paralegal or other staff person has the skill to review bank and brokerage statements. Unfortunately, hidden assets are not usually in bank or brokerage statements. Illinois Courts are less tolerant of violations of discovery rules even at the expense of the case being decided. This means that if a party “stonewalls” and does not produce reasonably requested documents, the court can decide the case against the stonewalling party. Forensic accountants understand what records or documents are required in constructing income from lifestyle and income of businesses from sources that attorneys may not be knowledgeable of. The spouse found herself at trial and the attorneys could not prove the husband had any income except for family trusts (premarital or inherited). Therefore, the spouse received no maintenance after a 30 year marriage. She cried, not knowing where the monies were to come from to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars of legal fees or where she would find the funds to pay her rent and ordinary living expenses – while her ex-husband drives luxury cars and vacations several times a year at exotic locations. These cases are sad and can be prevented. Individuals considering a divorce retain divorce attorneys who meet their required criteria, but they should also engage a forensic accountant who will represent them and will independently answer their questions and their fears. The forensic accountant will work with the attorney and will maintain their independence so that you are informed with the facts as they are determined. Lawyers and their legal assistants are not forensic accountants nor have they most likely received advanced forensic training. They are knowledgeable in law and what it takes to handle your divorce with its unique issues. The forensic accountant may be engaged to perform the following tasks in a divorce.
- Identify and locate assets.
- Perform internet investigations.
- Determine the income of the other party.
- Provide for a valuation of assets
- Determine cash flow.
- Identify and quantify marital monies that may have been misused.
- And other accounting issues that would best assist the attorneys in court
More Blog Posts
In the past the beginning of March has always meant certain things to me – we have endured the worst weather of another Chicago winter and spring is close; the groundhog has seen his “tax” shadow so there is only six more weeks of tax season; golf season will soon be here; and a funny John Belushi bit about March coming in like a lion (worth the YouTube search).
When I’m not creating innovative tax and financial strategies for clients, you can usually find me on the golf course. Golf checks a lot of boxes for me. I originally started to play as I saw others developing relationships and business on the golf course. Having never played, I immediately went for some lessons. The first time I hit a four iron long and straight, I was hooked.
In January 2018, I began working at CJBS as an intern at the start of tax season. I was very grateful for the opportunity as I hadn’t had much experience with other organizations by then. It turns out CJBS was the best fit for me. Even during the interview, I knew CJBS was different. My interviewer put me at ease and was both encouraging and supportive, going so far as to offer me advice on my career path during our conversation.
One of the best professional decisions I have ever made was to attend the career fair at Loyola University in September 2018. It was then that I first met members from CJBS. After witnessing my husband’s experience with one of the Big 4 accounting firms, I knew that I would prefer to work at a medium‐sized public accounting firm. What was a great fit for him, was probably not ideal for me.
Last fall, after applying for a summer internship, I had my first conversation with members of the CJBS team via a virtual interview. Right away I knew that CJBS would be a perfect fit. Both Ryan and Susan were welcoming on the call and we connected over their description that accounting is like puzzle solving. […]
As the new year rang in, 2020 was going to be my year! I had just earned my B.A. in Accounting in December, bought our first home with my boyfriend in August, and quit my 14-year job in retail management to start my tax internship at CJBS in January—what could go wrong, right? Back in […]